Episode 81

David Ben-Gurion

  • 20:23
  • 2023
We kick off our new series - a deep dive into Megillat Ha’Atzmaut, or the Declaration of Independence - with the man who needs no introduction: Israel’s first Prime Minister, David Ben-Gurion
David Ben-Gurion

David Ben-Gurion, perhaps the most influential Jewish leader since Moses, needs no introduction. Here though are a few facts about Israel’s first Prime Minister:

It was he who on May 12th, 1948 advocated for what became the name of the State, dismissing the options of Judea, Zion, and Eretz Israel. It was he who pushed – more than anyone else – for the Declaration of Independence, even as Jerusalem and large swaths of the Galilee were cut off, Kibbutz Kfar Etzion had just fallen, and the US, days earlier, had explicitly warned that it would not come to the aid of a young state in the event of a military defeat, which – by the way – seemed entirely possible.

It was he who wrote in his diary on the day of the Declaration, quote, “at four o’clock in the afternoon, Jewish independence was declared and the State was founded. Its fate is in the hands of the armed forces.” It was he who – just five weeks after the founding of the State – gave the order to open fire on the Irgun’s arms ship, the Altalena; a decision that some saw as a test of true leadership and others as a murderous act that would result in civil war. It was he who – though himself a socialist – charted Israel’s course away from the Soviet Union and he who – years later – gave the order to capture Adolf Eichmann and bring him to trial in Jerusalem.

Finally, it was he who – while shepherding the State into existence and shaping more or less all of its institutions from the Mossad to the IDF, from the Histadrut Labor Union to the national Bible Quiz – was forced by his wife Paula to eat the same bland porridge, a blend of applesauce and sour cream that she called “cooch mooch,” every day for breakfast.

David Ben-Gurion

The thirty-seven people who signed Megillat Ha’Atzmaut on May 14, 1948, represented many factions of the Jewish population: There were revisionists and Labor Party apparatchiks; capitalists and communists and socialists; kibbutznikim, moshavnikim and city-folk; charedi rabbis and atheists.

Over the course of the past several months, our team has diligently tracked down the closest living relative of each one of these signatories, and interviewed them. We talked about their ancestors and families, about the promise of the Declaration, the places in which we delivered on that promise, the places in which we exceeded our wildest dreams, and also about the places where we fell short.

And it is through these descendants of the men and women who – with the strike of a pen – gave birth to this country of ours, that we wish to learn something about ourselves.

Today we’ll meet David Ben-Gurion, and his eldest grandson, Yariv Ben-Eliezer. He’ll present one of the many political perspectives we’ll be featuring throughout the series.

Yariv Ben-Eliezer: People started running in the street and dancing. He was alone in a room. My uncle Amos asked him, “daddy, why don’t you go out with the street and dancing with the people?” He said, “I’m sad because I know how much blood will be shed for our independence.”

[Signed, Sealed, Delivered? introduction]

Mishy Harman (narration): Ben-Gurion, perhaps the most influential Jewish leader since Moses, needs no introduction. Here though are a few facts about Israel’s first Prime Minister:

It was he who on May 12th, 1948 advocated for what became the name of the State, dismissing the options of Judea, Zion, and Eretz Israel. It was he who pushed – more than anyone else – for the Declaration of Independence, even as Jerusalem and large swaths of the Galilee were cut off, Kibbutz Kfar Etzion had just fallen, and the US, days earlier, had explicitly warned that it would not come to the aid of a young state in the event of a military defeat, which – by the way – seemed entirely possible.

It was he who wrote in his diary on the day of the Declaration, quote, “at four o’clock in the afternoon, Jewish independence was declared and the State was founded. Its fate is in the hands of the armed forces.” It was he who – just five weeks after the founding of the State – gave the order to open fire on the Irgun’s arms ship, the Altalena; a decision that some saw as a test of true leadership and others as a murderous act that would result in civil war. It was he who – though himself a socialist – charted Israel’s course away from the Soviet Union and he who – years later – gave the order to capture Adolf Eichmann and bring him to trial in Jerusalem.

Finally, it was he who – while shepherding the State into existence and shaping more or less all of its institutions from the Mossad to the IDF, from the Histadrut Labor Union to the national Bible Quiz – was forced by his wife Paula to eat the same bland porridge, a blend of applesauce and sour cream that she called “cooch mooch,” every day for breakfast.

Here’s Ben-Gurion addressing the Knesset and discussing Israel’s future on the occasion of his 85th birthday, in 1971, two years before his death:

David Ben-Gurion: We cannot boast that the nation in Israel is already an exemplary nation. And our international status will be determined neither by our supposed material wealth, nor by our military might, but by the moral light of our undertaking. And though there are menacing shadows, significant ones, above us right now, we have grounds to believe that we can be an exemplary nation!

Yariv Ben-Eliezer: My name is Dr. Yariv Ben-Eliezer. I’m a professor of communication. The State was created when I was eight. I didn’t know anything. I mean, I didn’t know that my grandfather is such an important person. When I started elementary school, I realized that I belong to a very famous family because kids were teasing me and singing songs about my grandpa, and I would fight them. It was not so easy. Then I started dating. If after a week the girl would say, “let’s see your grandpa.” I said, “then she doesn’t like me, she likes my grandfather.” Dropped her. After a couple of cases like this, I met my late wife. She said something good about Begin, I said, ‘OK, she doesn’t love my grandfather, she loves me.’ So I offer her to marry and we got married after six months. We were children. She was nineteen, I was twenty-and-a-half, I was still in the military. And I would run through the fences almost every night to see my wife, and paid for that in prison, but that’s a different story. My grandfather has a problem with height, because he was a short guy. So when he saw her, he said “wow, good, you brought a tall girl to the family and a beautiful one.” And there was a love affair between them. I remember that one day we came for a visit. And my grandma asked her, “Dalia, there is no clothing in Israel that you have to go with a mini?” So my grandfather said, “it’s nice, she has beautiful legs.” I loved him so much. He was a great person. On top of everything, he was a genius in many respects. He knew many languages. He learned Spanish just to read Don Quixote. He learned Greek just to read Aplaton. I mean, he’s crazy, but unique. He has a great personality when he talks. aAnd I’m sure that if he had been here today, he could have been a great contender to Prime Minister as far as media is concerned.

David Ben-Gurion: So I thought the attitude to all Germans as to Nazis is wrong. It’s unjust. I couldn’t say that Adenauer is a Nazi, he was not a Nazi.

Broadcaster: Violent demonstrations throughout Israel today. “Blood money, guilt money,” screamed the crowd, as stones were thrown at the parliament building.

David Ben-Gurion: I wish the chancellor every success in his efforts to guide Germany in its path of democracy and international cooperation. Thank you very much.

Yariv Ben-Eliezer: Begin was considered to be a great democrat. He gathered thousands of his supporters, like the Bibis today, each of them holding a rock. And he said to them, “because of the agreement Ben-Gurion made with the Germans, I’m telling you today, ‘blood!’” And they all went to the Parliament — to the Knesset — and threw rocks at the Knesset.

Broadcaster: At the center of the storm are the negotiations between Israel and Western Germany on reparations to compensate the survivors of Hitler’s concentration camps. The survivors insist genocide has no price.

Yariv Ben-Eliezer: I couldn’t forget it to Begin. All the shtick that he did? Fine with me, but trying to throw stones and rocks at the Knesset?! The same situation occurs in Israel today. Binyamin Netanyahu is in power fifteen years. He divided Israel to those who are his followers, we call them ‘Bibistim,’ and those who don’t. Luckily, most of those who don’t live in Tel Aviv, so I’m living in a bubble, and I live my life quietly. I’m considered to be [in Hebrew] a leftist, because I believe in equality and socialism and freedom to the Palestinian and everything. So I’m a traitor. I went to school at NYU for six years, and I wish Israel will be like Manhattan – live and let live, liberal, patient, tolerant. I envy them. I mean, I would say in one sentence: The country is beautiful. The people of Israel are shit. He was very realistic. He had vision. He was like a prophet in this case. I remember very well the last chapter — he wrote it not just signed it — and it says, Israel will take care of equality between people based on age, gender, ethnicity, nationality. You see, he believed that Israel would be an example to the other nations, and the people of Israel will be what he called [in Hebrew] ‘a treasured people.’ And this is not! Israel became now a state of apartheid. It was a vision that went down the drain. This is not the dream of the beginners of Israel, and it was not the dream of my grandfather. It’s a nightmare. Half of the people will go to the army, and half of the people will study Torah. Fuck! I don’t want it. I have grandchildren. They’re going to the army, fight for what? For the Hasidic who are sitting masturbating and getting money from my taxes. This is not the people I want to live with. When I see what’s happening in Israel, I’m so proud of my grandfather and sad for him. I’m glad that he didn’t see that troubled country now. I’m glad that he can’t see that. It would have killed him. I’m an optimistic person. I never give up. I believe that eventually [in Hebrew] “the glory of Israel will not lie,” we will survive all the troubles and win.

Further Reading

There is, needless to say, endless material about David Ben-Gurion. Here is a selected list of primary source material and secondary literature that we found particularly helpful while working on the episode:

For a wonderful 2016 documentary film based on a 1968 interview with Ben-Gurion, see Yariv Mozer’s Ben Gurion, Epilogue (pay per view)

Credits

Mitch Ginsburg and Lev Cohen are the senior producers of Signed, Sealed, Delivered? This episode was recorded at Nomi Studios and was mixed by Sela Waisblum. Zev Levi scored and sound designed it with music from Blue Dot Sessions. Our music consultants are Tomer Kariv and Yoni Turner, and our dubber is Yoav Yefet.

The end song is Shir Ba’Boker Ba’Boker (lyrics – Amir Gilboa, music – Gideon Koren and Shlomo Artzi, arrangement – Yaron Gershovsky), performed by Shlomo Artzi.

This series is dedicated to the memory of David Harman, who was a true believer in the values of the Declaration of Independence, in Zionism, in democracy and – most of all – in equality.